13 November 2011

David Warner to replace Shaun Marsh

*News: Cricket writer and commentator Peter Roebuck committed suicide. I enjoyed some his work a few years back and listened to a bit of his commentary, seems quite a heavy incident. You can read the article surrounding this incident at Cricinfo.

Due to the injury our quickly settled Baggy Greener, Shaun Marsh, picked up during the 1st Test, David Warner has been named the replacement.
It is one of the final calls from the FNSP (Former-National Selection Panel) to make and a good one.
David has been in sensational form with the longer form of the game for New South Wales, not to forget the tour to Zimbabwe where he represented Australia A dominantly.

Even though it is highly unlikely he will play with Usman Khawaja coming in for Shaun, the thought of the Warner/Watto duo doesn't seem as appealing for tests as it is in limited overs.
There has been a bigger call now than ever for Watto to slip down the order.
In many ways I agree with this. I know Watto works bloody hard at his game for both batting and bowling and recently made mention of his shift in mindset for the two roles.
My concern though rests more with the threat he puts his body under with his soon to increase work-load, as opposed to just moving him down based on his run returns as an opening batsman.

There was the JL and Haydos partnership, the Tubby Taylor and Slats partnership, not to forget the well merged and recently disbanded Watto/Katto partnership.
What seemed to work was the aggressive player feeding off the cautious, more conservative batsman.
The talk of Watto moving down is good. We have Shaun Marsh (injury pending) who slotted in brilliantly at number three and the shift up isn't all that out of the ordinary for a number 3 to open. It can be the same role in many quick wicket circumstances.
Usman Khawaja has been hitting the nets hard and posting good individual scores each season. The man is a traditionalist.
While both Usman and Shaun have the ability to play conservatively, seeing out the good deliveries and then dispatching the rubbish to get their runs, I like the idea of say David Warner one day earning his Baggy Green to open alongside one of them with Punter having moved down to occupy a middle order position.

-----------------------------------------
A stats inclusion:
Justin Langer and Matty Hayden produced 6081 runs, from 122 innings, at a 51.53 average. They had a telepathic connection which went well beyond the playing field. Their impact scarred many tight bowling units.

The Mark Taylor and Michael Slater partnership managed 3887 runs, from 78 innings, at an average of 51.14.

Watto and Simon Katich managed 1529 runs, from 29 innings, at an average of 52.72.

Phillip Hughes briefly partnered Simon Katich.
It was a partnership which flourished in certain matches with an overall return of 604 runs, from 11 innings at an average of 60.40.

By contrast the aggressive/aggressive match of Hughes and Watto has produced 472 runs in 15 innings at an average of 31.46.


-------------------------------------------

Quite a few months back he (Warner) made a statement of his eagerness to earn the cap despite all the hype over his Twenty20 game. That statement made me want to see him get there because he has his eye set on the pinnacle of the game, a hunger to be the best cricketer he can at the elite level.
He's certainly showing a change in temperament and with a tight technique and the performances he's putting in, I see no harm in the move. It is positive in my eyes.

Phillip Hughes is a young guy I feel quite upset for. I think he was built up way too much by the media following his maiden series but then Freddie Flintoff decided to change things, immediately adding huge pressure onto him as a young, newly recruited top level cricketer.
It doesn't change the obvious fact that Phillip will need a good Test match and is certainly feeling the heat of the pressure to perform at the elite level. He always backs himself but you get the feeling that this is his final chance for the summer.
Fortunately he's a young man so time is well on his side.

It is hard for a young man to cop the criticism he has and the concern from the supporters seem to be that quality bowlers figure him out.
I know that he spent two hours in the nets at Newland's alongside our maestro Ricky Ponting, working with Justin Langer, which also continued on what would have been Day 5 of the Test.
It was an optional training session on the Saturday and these guys got straight to work sparing little time for a breather.
Most people don't see this and I respect that work the boys put in.

I hope it pays off for them come the 2nd Test where the deck will be better suited to their games and they need our support even if it seems some changes are going to be needed or inevitably made.

I think come the flight back to Australia the boys may cop a fair bit from the media despite what the result in the 2nd Test may be because the 1st Test will forever be in the record books and it hurt.
As I've mentioned though, it's a game of cricket and life moves on and what we need to do is give these blokes the support they deserve.
It's far better than jumping aboard with the Hate Club, which will just sink your integrity.

Supporters have a right to voice their frustration with what we invest in the game and some feel more hard done by than others after that Test and the frequency of batting collapses.
Yes, we are the ones who keep the game alive, however these guys are the professionals, they are the ones who get given a hard time and they are the ones to turn it around and we can help them in doing so!
What do we do when we're down? We get back up and look ahead.

The 2nd Test will bring about some potential final changes, with Usman set to make his return, while the hype is out there about Patty Cummins getting his Baggy Green cap handed down to him, which will mark him as cap #423.
Very excited for him.

Change awaits for the summer and the new selection panel will be right into the action for the Chappell-Hadlee series with the Border-Gavaskar to follow.
Come on Baggy Greens, throw us back on track for the next Test!

Welcome to The Baggy Green Blog! Thanks for reading this article written by Ian.
To comment on this article, click on the 'Comments' tag at the end of the article.
TWITTER
@BaggyGreenBlog
@Ianbaggygreen
@Dan_Stapo

12 comments:

ajenko80 said...

Warner has played 1 Shield game this season. Sure he hit 148, but the game saw 2 centuries, 1 double cenury and 2 scores in the 90s. I know he's only going as back up I'm just not sure the antidote is super aggressive bats at the moment.I do rate Warner, don't get me wrong, just need to see a full season of scores.

Western Australia's Liam Davis and Adam Voges are among the runs and could be considered.

Unfortunately the first class season is split in two this season; with little cricket played ,on the domestic 4 day front, when New Zealand and India are present in the country.

Will be interesting to see how players transition ,if needed by their country, from T20 duties to the 5 day game.

https://seeballhitball.wordpress.com/

Ian said...

Yes, it's a very good point you've raised however there will be a bit of trusting instinct on a call-up such as David Warner's.

There's a few other contenders besides Davis and Adam, but while I personally think David has worked hard to transform his game, the thing is for a while the previous selectors were after the next big superstar, as opposed to just finding guys who would potentially just be solid test cricketers. This is why I like the inclusions of Shaun Marsh and Usman Khawaja, a while back Marcus North.

It's going to be a manic summer and in all honesty, I hope the players manage the workload alright. Quite a mash of formats too.

Shruthi said...

Good article, you have mentioned some very good points. I too think calling David Warner up was a positive move, but as you said, there is Usman Khwaja. But I am confident that that earning that cap is not far away for Warner. Like you said in the article, he has tightened his technique and has worked on his temperament. What do you think about Mitchell Johnson at the moment, Ian? There have been quite a few critics for him lately.

Ian said...

Hi Shruthi

Thanks for your comment again.
Glad you agree on David's call-up. Got to find positivity.

Mitch, tough one mate.
MJ is such a confidence driven player. We all know he is an X factor player and leaving him out will always cast doubt. He's scary to face but seems to depend heavily on a sort of "snow ball" effect for his self-confidence.

He's a good bloke who enjoys the game and is valued by his teammates, but the reality is the value we have in him that is hard to find elsewhere only shows up every now and then. I once wrote that a team like the Proteas who have a similar in value Dale Steyn to what we have in MJ can fortunately expect the X factor Steyn to show up 8 times out of 10.

It will get to a point where perhaps the new selection panel will opt for a bowling unit that can deliver consistency as opposed to potential match-winning heroes.
It's frustrating for MJ but I can't see it going on for too long. 2nd Test is just around the corner so don't rule him out.

But yes, MJ and a few of the other guys may be under a fair bit of pressure at the moment.

Your view on Mitch?

Shruthi said...

Oh I see..
Recently, I have been following Australian Cricket through the newspapers, so I have not exactly seen Mitchell Johnson bowling of-late. The last time I saw him bowl in Test Cricket was in Bangalore against India last year, where I thought he was not bad at all. I have always thought of him as a good bowler, a decent lower order bat and as you said yourself, a good character.

However, in recent times, he has not been performing too well, which has raised quite a few eyebrows. I read a recent article on the blog "Cricket through the eyes of an Irishman" where the author was particularly scathing on Mitchell Johnson. He mentioned a few names in Australian Domestic Cricket like James Faulkner and Luke Butterworth, who have been consistent performers in the domestic circuit, worthy of that position. So,Mitch is definitely under a bit of pressure, also as you said, the new selection panel might be looking for consistency. Lets hope Mitch is back soon.

I have also heard good stuff about Nic Maddinson.

Shruthi said...

I also like Shaun Marsh.
I felt bad for him that he got injured and was unable to continue in this series. But Warner was a good call-up.

Baiju Nair said...

Ian,

Good to see the journey of Warner, from a sensational 'out of nowhere' T20I debut to the threshold of baggy green...impressive.

Mate who do you reckon should be the openers if Phil is gonna get the boot and Watto sliding down the order. I would like to hear your views on Shaun as one of the opener..as the guy had good success at the top in ODIs. And Khawaja...?? Has he opened in shield cricket..?? I still think they dumped Katich too soon. The bloke had an year or so left in him. Now they gonna miss him shud Watto comes down the order...Stability at the top is a must especially with Punter looking out of sorts..

Waiting for Pat Cummins' debut..

Ian said...

Baiju, my good man. Hope you are well buddy.

"Mate who do you reckon should be the openers if Phil is gonna get the boot and Watto sliding down the order?"
Shaun Marsh could slot in perfectly. Number 3 is as good as an opener if you lose a quick wicket. Injury burdens will be all that stands in his way. He has adapted so quickly.
A good duo: Marsh and Warner.
Two lefties, one aggressive, one cautious opener, but Warner has yet to even receive a Baggy Green but he is getting exposure so you have to ponder it.

"And Khawaja...?? Has he opened in shield cricket..??"
As for Usman, yes he has opened, so he is seasoned with the new ball but, unlike Shaun, he has had sufficient opportunities or just not occupied enough crease time in the middle, so you have a potential opener/ number 3 prospect.
This is all working on assumptions could Phillip could come right. Punter has already shifted down from number 3.

"I would like to hear your views on Shaun as one of the opener..as the guy had good success at the top in ODIs."
I may have touched on this during the Sri Lankan series. I see little difference between a number 3 and 1/2, given a wicket in the first promotes you to the duty of the fallen opener.
He'd be perfectly fine having seen how he's applied himself thus far with his Test match innings.

I hate the thought of someone being dropped, but the general talk out there is a few blokes will be under-fire.
The new selection panel will be making the first move after the 2nd test match.
But the top order is something I would be happy to see change.

Joshua James Robert said...

Hello Ian,

Read about you in Cricinfo.I was suprised to find some one like me! I was born and grew in India and have been watching Cricket since 1996 WC, and since day1 i am an ardent Aussie Fan.So it was a great feeling to know about you and about this blog! And just like you, i dont see gloom and doom for our team, i only see bright days ahead!Surely i will visit this blog often and will share my views! Thank God for people like you!!!

Regards,
Joshua,Chennai, India.

Ian said...

Joshua, fantastic to have your opinion shared here and furthermore that you're also a Baggy Green fanatic from another part of the world!

I was expecting a few people to head over regarding Brydon's article.

That's the great thing I find with modern day sport. No barries, no limits and it just enhances the unity of people who avidly follow the game and the team. Thanks for checking out the blog as well.

For sure, whenever you're keen to share your opinion on an article do exactly what you just did.

Keep up the support. The team needs it. Chat more as the 2nd Test progresses.

Ian said...

Good timing too, was just checking the blog.

Joshua said...

Thanks Ian for your great gesture!

I feel the following XI will be great for tomorrow, in the following order.I think our captain posses one of the best minds in modern cricket, so whatever he decides regd the squad, he would be right i believe! I think our team can square up the series by winning this test!

Khawaja
Hughes
Ponting
Clarke
Hussey
Watson
Haddin
Johnson
Harris
Cummins
Lyon